Access count of this item: 146

Files in This Item:
File Description SizeFormat 
cap_10_66.pdf489.04 kBAdobe PDFView/Open
Title: <研究論文(原著論文)>健康の必要十分条件を与える試み : アリストテレス的全体論の提案
Authors: 杉本, 俊介  KAKEN_name
Keywords: 健康
医学の哲学
ブールス
ノルデンフェルト
アリストテレス
Issue Date: 26-Apr-2019
Publisher: Japanese Association for the Contemporary and Applied Philosophy (JACAP)
Journal title: Contemporary and Applied Philosophy
Volume: 10
Start page: 66
End page: 92
Abstract: In my paper, I examine previous attempts to provide a necessary and sufficient condition of health and propose and defend what I call the Aristotelian holistic theory of health. In Section 2, I discuss Germund Hesslow's view that defining such a condition is of no significance and argue against his view by emphasising the theoretical and practical significance of clearly defining health. In Section 3, I examine Christopher Boorse's functional account on health, according to which health is the absence of disease. I argue that the functional account does not fit the world disease classification and makes the intergenerational comparison questionable. I also argue that it contradicts both preventive medicine and psychiatry and concedes a part of Hesslow's view. Furthermore, I argue that Boorse's critique of positive health complicates our attempt at defining health. In Section 4, I examine Lennart Nordenfelt's holistic theory of health, which is intuitive because it includes 'second-order ability' and 'standard circumstances'. I argue that the holistic theory does not solve the difficulty proposed by Boorse. In Section 5, I also examine the Aristotelian accounts provided by Christopher Megone and Philippa Foot. I argue that it is not clear that the Aristotelian accounts do not capture our intuition on health, although they do circumvent the difficulty proposed by Boorse. In Section 6, I propose and defend the compromise, the Aristotelian holistic theory of health. In addition, I explore what this view implies.
URI: http://hdl.handle.net/2433/241125
Related Link: https://jacap.org/journal/
Appears in Collections:vol. 10

Show full item record

Export to RefWorks


Export Format: 


Items in DSpace are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.