Access count of this item: 398

Files in This Item:
File Description SizeFormat 
KER-79(2)_Onishi.pdf100.03 kBAdobe PDFView/Open
Title: A Different Attitude for Mathematical Formularization between Marxian and Western Economics
Authors: Onishi, Hiroshi
Keywords: Mathematical modeling
Marxian economics
Western economics
historical materialism
Peer Review System
Issue Date: Dec-2010
Publisher: Graduate School of Economics, Kyoto University
Citation: Onishi, Hiroshi; "A Different Attitude for Mathematical Formularization between Marxian and Western Economics", The Kyoto Economic Review, Vol. 79, pp.110-122 (2010) .
Journal title: The Kyoto economic review
Volume: 79
Issue: 2
Start page: 110
End page: 122
Abstract: Mathematical modeling is more advanced in modern economics than in Marxist economics. But why is this? One answer deals with the characteristics of modern economics, which ignore what mathematics is not good at. Another answer is that Western economics assumes that a human being is a "rational economic man, " prompting economists to use the optimization theory. Many "Marxian economists" do not like this assumption. However, in my opinion, a "rational economic man" is a materialistic concept of a human being, so I built two types of Marxian models based on the optimization theory: Lenin's model of imperialism and the "Marxian optimal growth model." One more important characteristic of mathematical modeling is that it makes science progress incrementally, which gives modern economics a tendency to avoid challenging researches in a referee system of their journals. However, this type of attitude becomes an obstacle to explain phenomena that have not been seen before or do not fit their ideologies. In this sense, mathematics has to be used by ideologically free scientists; that is, Marxists. In this paper, we also referred to characteristics of "area studies" in comparing with Marxist methodologies.
DOI: 10.11179/ker.79.110
URI: http://hdl.handle.net/2433/158204
Appears in Collections:Vol.79 No.2

Show full item record

Export to RefWorks


Export Format: 


Items in DSpace are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.